Feedback:
Tom
Good job on your analysis of the issues. He now has an understanding of the town.
-include a sense of what the community wants & ideas of how you might go about it
Programmatically this has to be something that you feel strongly about because it won’t get built exactly as you conceive it.
Challenge is going to be focus-big site-connections to the other side of the river.
Eric Nelson
Show the edge of the river. Is it controlled?
Show the flatness also when showing the mountain contour
Likes the image with the White Mountain in the distance
Mike
Commends your very good analysis
Intrigued by a post industrial aspect of mill towns. How do you propose a landscape intervention to restore the site? This is a huge site = massive intervention. How do you gauge your level of success on a site of this scale – how do you criticize it?
Eric Nelson
This is a huge site, but there is definitely a center-the old mill.
I would look at the adaptive reuse of the structure as an important piece of the town.
Doesn’t buy the program of the AMC. This is an industrial town, not a dense urban area.
Could see a school or community college for the town as a means of educating the generation that lost their jobs when the mill closed.
Personally doesn’t see the smoke stack as the icon, but the fantastic masses of the building.
Maybe you could keep the machinery and add to it in a light, more delicate way.
Mike W.
The Tate Modern kept the industrial feel of the building and put a museum in it. Check it out.
Curt
There are two towns here Berlin A & Berlin B
What would be a signature project that would speak to what can happen in the future as other phases happen over the next 50 years.
Capture, analyze and diagram the industry of the town so that if you’re going to do a park it references the history of the industry.
Mountains in the background remind him of the Architecture of Crete. Valley Architecture that honored its position and the relationship to the mountains.
Mike?
Precedent was interesting that you give something back to the town by way of energy &/or restoration
Herb
What happens when mills close? You loose your $, friends, sense of ritual, smell. This is a landscape that is going to change from masculine to feminine. You don’t have to talk about it or think about it, you just do it. If you change it, it will take on a feminine roll of hosting, being articulate, etc. Watch movie “Roger & Me”.
The most important question is what comes after industry in an emotional sense? How do you accommodate the change to feminine?
Mike?
Is this going to be a building, landscape plan, series of bridges, park? What is the scale of your project? Is it 120 acres or 120 square feet?
Curt
Even if it is a building, landscape is still very important.
Mike?
Tschumi’s large project or is it a small piece?
Curt
This is going to be a town based on the scale. It is too large for a park. You could either dive into or assume an urban plan, with a town square.
Eric Nelson
The factory was something that took natural resources from the area. What if that gets reversed and the plant feeds the town.
Curt
Richard Russo “Empire Falls”
Herb
This is going to be a change in character, it is going to become a serving rather than taking.
Curt
The scale of the factory needs to be evaluated for whatever program you choose. May not be right for a town square or park.
Tom
Selectively pick one opportunity, but talk about the 5-10-15 that you’ve come up with. You don’t have to do something with all of them.
Mike
Scale of the AMC Ed Center program gets lost on this site.
Herb
Be careful about jobs=jobs. The types of careers here are not the same. One does not replace the other. What is the nature of the work? If you were not to do a physical intervention, what would be the principles of your thesis? What is the emotional intervention?
No comments:
Post a Comment